The first thing that strikes you while reading Emma Donoghue’s ‘Room’ is Jack’s innocence, wisdom, and love for his Ma. But would not that be obvious? What else a 5 year old should be full of?

from google images

And that is why I liked ‘Room’. Because the unusual situation the child and the parent are in (I am trying really hard to avoid spoilers here), telling the story through Jack’s eyes. Of course that way you don’t get to understand a lot of whys but it is a pretty unbiased view. In the sense, you do not really think about why the bad stuff happened, or why did the mother do so and not so. To me that was a narrative triumph. 


*spoiler/s ahoy (cant resist myself anymore)*
Also makes me wonder, how would I like to be ‘Outside’ not knowing there was an ‘Outside’. But then I haven’t been isolated for more than 7 days (knowing there is an Outside) and I have just discussed with brother how that austrian man should be punished (the story is inspired from that incident) and read about the stockholm syndrome. (talking/knowing about something and actually experiencing are a little tangential things, no?)


Of course, everyone finds closure and deals with the ‘Outside’ in their own way. Everyone has their own ‘Room’ too. Its unsettling to be in Jack and Ma’s shoes though. Physically.
As Jack would say, I would say everyone feels a little ‘scave’ (that’s scared + brave) all the time.


-nightflier

P.S. As usual while reading the book I had this *thought* that someone should make a hindi movie on the book with Vidya Balan as Ma. 


8 responses to “Jack be nimble, Jack be quick..”

  1. nightflier Avatar

    πŸ™‚ agree!!
    Also, explains, why I give books the time whenever I have some free πŸ˜€

  2. neha Avatar

    so many books to read, so little time!! πŸ™ (but then, ofcourse, one can make time!)

  3. nightflier Avatar

    I actually did not think about this at all πŸ™ Now that you say it, makes me wonder too..
    may be it could have been possible to leave those aspects out and concentrate on the psychological aspects only.

  4. nightflier Avatar

    I hope you get back to reading as much as you want, as soon as possible πŸ™‚

  5. nightflier Avatar

    Offo πŸ™ actually I am going through the dry phase in other departments of life, so this extra activity on the reading front.. I am sure I will have dry reading spells as well πŸ™‚

  6. Upasna Avatar

    the one thing I did *not* like about it was this- she says in the middle that one shouldn't 'sell' such a story or something to tht effect, while the whole story is in many ways very tabloid driven as a plot…however, there are aspects esp from Jack which are very observant and detailed!

  7. Purvi Avatar

    Reading has taken a backseat for me for very long now… got to do something about it πŸ™‚

  8. Tanvi Avatar

    *hmmm* Your blog is a constant reminder to me of what a BAD person I am in terms of my READING! πŸ™ …

    β™‘ from Β© tanvii.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *